Guinness punch pie

Not yet rated

This Guinness punch pie by Melissa Thompson is inspired by Jamaican Guinness punch. Unlike British punch - which tends to be fruity and based on juice - Guinness punch is creamy, and made with Guinness (of course), condensed milk and vanilla Nurishment. This pie is absolutely delicious and sure to become a favourite with anyone who tries it.

This recipe is taken from Motherland by Melissa Thompson (Bloomsbury Publishing, £26). Photography by Patricia Niven.

First published in 2023
discover more:

Melissa says: "If you like custard tarts, you will love this. I first had the idea for it a few years ago, while drinking some Guinness punch and wondering if it would translate into dessert form. The answer was a resounding yes. The flavours work really well in a tart and you can adjust the intensity of the Guinness flavour by using slightly less or more. And if you don’t drink alcohol you can use 0% Guinness: it works, I’ve tried.

Stout is a really popular drink in Jamaica, with Guinness and Dragon Stout cornering the market. Guinness followed the British Empire – it is also huge in Nigeria – and the company first exported a West Indian porter from Dublin to the island in 1801, with the first export of proper Guinness going out in 1830. Its long-standing history on the island is immortalised in Guinness Punch (see page 265 of Melissa’s book Motherland) and this tart takes on those flavours beautifully. The slight bitterness of stout is softened by sweetness here, while the spices in the custard are really reminiscent of the stout itself. The tart makes a brilliant centrepiece, and will bring smiles of contentment to fans of the drink, as well as to everyone else."




For the custard

For the pastry

  • 125g of unsalted butter, plus more for the tin
  • 250g of plain flour, plus more to dust
  • 45g of golden caster sugar
  • 1 egg yolk
  • 30ml of water


  • 20cm loose-bottomed tart tin
  • Baking beans



In a saucepan, simmer the Guinness until it reduces by about two-thirds. Leave to cool

  • 400ml of Guinness

Meanwhile make the pastry. Using your hands, rub the butter and flour together until the mix resembles breadcrumbs. Mix in the sugar and egg yolk and then add the measured water a little bit at a time, until the dough comes together. Don't knead any more, just wrap in cling film or greaseproof paper and refrigerate for 30 minutes

  • 125g of unsalted butter, plus more for the tin
  • 250g of plain flour, plus more to dust
  • 45g of golden caster sugar
  • 1 egg yolk
  • 30ml of water

Preheat the oven to 160°C/fan 140°C/Gas Mark 3


Butter a 20cm tart tin and remove the pastry from the fridge. Dust your worktop with flour and roll out the pastry into a circle roughly 28cm in diameter


Coil the pastry around the rolling pin and uncoil over the tart tin. Carefully push the pastry into the corners of the tin and leave the edges rising above the edge. Prick the base of the tin with a fork all over, then line with greaseproof paper and baking beans or rice. Bake in the oven for 15 minutes


Take out the greaseproof paper and baking beans and bake for a further 5 minutes. Remove from the oven and leave to cool


In a bowl, gently beat the egg yolks with the condensed milk, trying not to get too much air or too many bubbles into the mix. Stir in the double cream and reduced Guinness, then stir in the remaining ingredients


Pour the custard into the pastry case and bake for 40-45 minutes; it should still have a wobble in the middle. Remove from the oven and leave to cool


Grate extra nutmeg over the top and chill before slicing

First published in 2023

Melissa Thompson is a London-based recipe developer and food writer of Jamaican and Maltese heritage. She runs food and recipe project Fowl Mouths and is a columnist for BBC Good Food. In 2022, Melissa released her debut cookbook Motherland, which celebrates the food of Jamaica.

Get in touch

Please sign in or register to send a comment to Great British Chefs.