Phil Carnegie's Scottish beef cooked two ways and served with extra special bone marrow is a week long job and involves a water bath. You can, however, be inspired by this exquisite beef fillet recipe and tweak it by cooking the meat in a more traditional way, perfect for a top notch sunday roast.

Marinade the feather blade in the red wine, port, vegetables, bay leaves and peppercorns for 5 days
After 5 days take out the feather blade and dry. Season the feather blade with salt and pepper and quickly brown all over in a frying pan
Drain the marinade through a sieve and pour the liquid into a saucepan. Add the vinegar and bring to the boil. Place the feather blade with some of the marinade into a vac pack and place into a water bath for 60 hours at 60°C
Alternatives to a water bath
If you don't have a water bath, simply use a slow cooker instead and follow the maker's instructions. Otherwise you can use a casserole and cook the meat for 50-60 minutes with the marinade.
Boil the rest of the marinade until reduced by half then add the veal stock and reduce by a third
To make the bone marrow dumplings, melt the bone marrow in a pan, then cool. Whisk in the egg yolks and parsley. Season with salt, pepper and nutmeg then add the breadcrumbs
Bring the chicken stock up to the boil, then reduce to a simmer. Roll the bone marrow mixture into balls and poach in the chicken stock for 5 minutes
Heat a frying pan and add a little oil. Season the tournedos and seal in the hot oil then add the 150g of butter and fry until cooked to your liking
For the watercress purée, bring a saucepan of salted water up to a boil, then add the watercress and cover the pan with a lid. When the watercress is cooked, drain it well, then refresh under cold water.
Blend the watercress in a food processor with two tablespoons of water. Scrape a spatula down the insides of the food processor then blend again until the mixture forms a smooth purée. Season, to taste, with salt and freshly ground black pepper
To make the red wine jus, heat a saucepan over a low heat. Squash the garlic cloves and drop them into the pan along with the wine and the rosemary. Allow to simmer over a medium heat until the liquid has reduced by half.
Give it a swirl around the pan every 10 minutes to combine. Once reduced, pour in the beef and chicken stocks. Reduce by half again. Strain through a fine sieve
Gently blanch the onions and carrots in boiling salted water until tender, then transfer to a pan of foaming hot butter. Toss for a few minutes and set aside until needed
To plate, spoon a generous helping of watercress purée onto the plate, and position the meat on top. Stack the carrots on top of one piece of meat, and position the onions and dumplings to the side. Spoon over a generous helping of the jus and serve
Send us feedback on this Beef fillet recipe  

Wine Matching

Find out why we suggest matching this Beef fillet recipe with a medium and round red wine, a spicy and rich red wine, or a full bodied red wine


Feather blade

Marrow dumplings

Watercress purée

Beef and red wine jus

To plate


  1. Vac pac maker
  2. Water bath

Share this Recipe

Scottish beef is prepared two ways in Phil Carnegie's impressive beef fillet recipe. Marrow dumplings add a special accent to this awe-inspiring beef meal.